|
Spring - Summer 2001
CODES AND SPECIFICATONS UNDERSTANDING AND
WORKING THROUGH THE MAZE
MATERIAL AND PRODUCT STANDARDS - PART
I
This
is Part I in a series of three articles to
understand and locate codes and specification
provisions related to concrete masonry design and
construction. The purpose of these articles is not
so much to provide specific design guidance, but to
direct a design engineer to various provisions,
primarily in the 1998 California Building Code.
Many other codes and standards such as ASTM,
UBC-Standards and Masonry Standards Joint Committee
(MSJC) provisions are also referenced where
appropriate.
Provisions in 1998 California Building Code are
discussed, rather than 1997 UBC Provisions, because
it is a document based on 1997 UBC adopted in
California and also covers State of California
Amendments, which are applicable to public schools,
community colleges, essential services buildings,
and hospitals.
The three part series is divided as follows:
Part I deals with Material and Product
Standards.
Part II will address Design
Provisions.
Part III covers Testing, Inspection,
and Construction.
A typical concrete masonry assemblage is a
complex system comprising of four primary
materials; concrete masonry units, mortar, grout,
and reinforcement. No unreinforced masonry is
permitted in seismic zones 3 and 4 of the Uniform
Building Code (1997 edition).
Each of the primary materials used has
significant variability in its properties, making
the entire assemblage difficult to analyze, design,
construct, and inspect.
Testing and inspection functions are
particularly important due to this inherent
complexity and variability to deliver a high degree
of quality in the final assemblage.
From a strictly definitional point of view,
concrete masonry units are considered "a product,"
not a material. Therefore, concrete masonry units
are discussed under the category of product.
MORTAR
Definition for mortar is given in Section 2103.3
of the California Building Code.
It is defined as:
|
·
|
A mixture of cementitious materials,
aggregates, water, and approved additives
to achieve workable plastic
consistency.
|
|
·
|
Mortar must conform to UBC Standard
21-15. This Standard is based on ASTM
Standard C270-95, with minor
modifications. As the latest version of
ASTM Standard is C270-99b, we will use
that as a reference Standard, because it
supercedes C270-95. This Standard is meant
for laboratory testing to specify mortar
properties, not for field testing of
mortar. Field samples of mortar are not
meant to comply with this Standard.
|
|
·
|
Cementitious materials that are
allowed:
Portland cement
mortar cement
Cementitious materials not
allowed:
epoxy resins and derivatives
phenols
asbestos fibers
fire clays
masonry cement
|
|
·
|
Although four types of mortars are
allowed, in Seismic zones 3 and 4 , only
type "M" and "S" are allowed. (Type "M"
for the State of California buildings such
as schools, community colleges and
hospitals, must meet the proportions of
type "S")
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Selection of proportions for mortar ingredients is
covered in Section 2103.3.2.
Two methods are allowed for specifying
mortar:
|
1.
|
Proportion specifications (by
volume)
- Table 21A.
|
|
2.
|
Property specifications (by required
compressive strength) - Section
2103A.3.2.
(State Amendment)
Minimum required compressive
strength is 1500 psi at 28 days for
masonry
with f 'm = 1500 psi.
It should be noted that this
compressive strength is to be measured on
a field test specimen prepared
according to UBC Standard 21-16. Since the
test specimen is a cylinder rather than a
cube, direct comparisons of laboratory
cube strength and field specimen cylinder
strength should not be made. Generally,
the cylinder strength is 85% of the cube
strength.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Typical mortar proportions are as follows:
|
|
Type "M"
|
Type
"S"
|
|
Portland cement
|
1
|
|
part
|
1
|
|
part
|
|
Lime
|
|
½
|
part
|
|
¼
|
part
|
|
Sand
|
4
|
½
|
parts
|
3
|
½
|
parts
|
|

|

|

|

|

|

|

|
Addition of lime to mortar improves:
a. Workability
b. Water penetration resistance
c. Water retentivity (usable life of
mortar)
Please note, "lime" is a cementitious
material, not an admixture or additive.
The compressive strength of mortar is sometimes
used as the main requirement for selecting a mortar
type. Compressive strength is easy to measure,
tests are well established and reliable, and can
give consistent results. The importance of
compressive strength of mortar though, is
overemphasized. Bond strength is generally more
important. Since good bond strength is also
dependent on water retentivity and workability,
these properties are important.
Compressive strength is measured on cube or
cylinder. However, the size effect needs to be
considered. A mortar joint has very high width to
thickness ratio. The ultimate compressive load
carrying capacity of a 3/8-inch thick bed joint is
deemed to be well over twice the compressive
strength of a mortar cube. For these reasons, Type
"S" mortar is preferable to type "M", although it
has lower compressive strength.
As a basic design philosophy, mortar should also
be weaker than masonry units so that the cracking
could occur in mortar joints instead of in the
masonry units, which are repairable.
GROUT
Definition for grout is given in Section
2103.4.
It is defined as:
|
·
|
A mixture of cementitious materials,
aggregates, additives, and water to allow
flow without segregation of the
constituents.
|
|
|
|
Terms "Grout lift" and "Grout pour" are misused
many times.
We are defining them here for clarity.
Grout lift is an increment of
grout height within total grout pour.
Grout pour is the total height of
masonry wall to be grouted prior to erection of
additional masonry. A grout pour consists of one or
more grout lifts.
|
·
|
Minimum specified compressive strength
to be 2000 psi at 28 days - section
2103.4.1.
|
|
·
|
Antifreeze compounds or air-entraining
agents are not allowed.
|
|
·
|
Additives and admixtures can be used
only when approved by the building
official or enforcing agency.
|
|
·
|
Grout must conform to UBC Standard
21-19, which is based on ASTM C476-99.
|
|
|
|
Selecting proportions for grout ingredients is
covered in Section 2103.4.2.
Grout can be specified by one of the three
methods:
|
1.
|
Proportion specifications (by
volume)
- Table 21-B.
|
|
2.
|
Minimum compressive strength, which
will produce required specified prism
strength.
|
|
3.
|
Laboratory or field experience with
grout ingredients and masonry units. Grout
to be proportioned by parts by volume of
its constituents.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
When specified by proportion of ingredients,
typical proportions by volume are as follows:
Fine Grout
|
Portland cement
|
1
|
|
part
|
|
Lime
|
Max 0
|
.1
|
part
|
|
Fine aggregates
|
3
|
|
parts
|
|
Coarse aggregates

|
--------
|
Coarse Grout
|
Portland cement
|
1
|
|
part
|
|
Lime
|
Max 0
|
.1
|
part
|
|
Fine aggregates
|
3
|
|
parts
|
|
Coarse aggregates

|
1
|
½
|
parts
|
|
|
|
Specifying grout by compressive strength at 28
days is common. Many times minimum specified
compressive strength is far in excess of masonry
unit strength or prism strength. This is not
necessary if adequate data exists. Code allows the
grout to be specified based on the data. In that
case, the proportion of ingredients needs to be
specified by volume.
CONCRETE MASONRY UNITS (CMU'S)
Primarily four types of CMU's are available;
load bearing, non-load bearing, concrete brick,
and segmental retaining wall units. Each
conforms to a different Standard of ASTM. Our focus
in this article is "load bearing units," as
it is the predominant product used in structural
masonry.
|
·
|
Must conform to ASTM C90-01. UBC
Standard 21-4 is still applicable, but is
based upon ASTM C90-95 version. One of the
prime changes in the latest ASTM
Specification is that differentiation of
masonry units as type I or type II has
been eliminated.
|
|
·
|
Concrete masonry units are classified
as; normal weight, medium weight, and
light weight.
|
Classification
|
Density
|
Maximum Water
Absorption
|
|
Light weight
|
< 105 pcf
|
18 pcf
|
|
Medium weight
|
105 to < 125
pcf
|
15 pcf
|
|
Normal weight
|
>125
pcf
|
13 pcf
|
|
|
·
|
All units have to meet a minimum
compressive strength calculated on average
net area.
|
|
Individual unit
|
-
|
Minimum 1700 psi.
|
|
|
Average of 3 units
|
-
|
Minimum 1900 psi.
|
|
|
·
|
Permissible variations in dimensions
for standard units are set as ± 1/8
inch. For special units different
standards may be applied.
|
|
·
|
Relationship between unit strength of
CMU and f 'm of masonry
assemblage varies because of variability
in mortar strength and grout strength, and
their interaction with the masonry unit in
generating compressive strength. When unit
strength of CMU is specified for a desired
f 'm , California
Building Code requires following minimum
unit strengths, based on Table 21D:
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
For Type M or S Mortar
|
Specified f
'm (psi)
|
Required Unit Strength
(psi)
|
|
1000
|
1250
|
|
|
1500
|
1900
|
|
|
2000
|
2800
|
|
|
2500
|
3750
|
|
|
3000
|
4800
|
or more
|
As one can see, the multiplier for required unit
strength varies from 1.25 at the low end to 1.60 at
the high end of f 'm . Linear
interpolation for values of f 'm
not listed in the table is allowed.
REINFORCEMENT
Reinforcement that is unique to concrete masonry
construction is joint reinforcing made from cold
drawn steel wire. This reinforcing consists of
deformed longitudinal wires welded to cross wires.
The joint reinforcing is placed in mortar joints
between masonry courses.
|
·
|
Joint reinforcing must conform to UBC
Standard 21-10 part I.
|
|
·
|
Some of the basic requirements are
|
1.
|
Longitudinal wires to be
minimum 0.148 inches in diameter
(9 gage), but not more than
one-half the mortar joint
thickness, which is typically 3/8
inch.
|
|
2.
|
Cross wires to be minimum
0.148 inches (9 gage) in
diameter, but not greater than
longitudinal wire diameter. Cross
wires not to project more than
1/8 inch beyond longitudinal
wires.
|
|
3.
|
Width of joint reinforcement
is defined as out to out distance
between longitudinal wires. 1/8
inch variation in width is
permitted.
|
|
4.
|
Length of pieces of joint
reinforcement not to vary by more
than ½ inch or 1% of the
length, whichever is smaller.
|
|
5.
|
Minimum required yield
strength of wires is 60 ksi with
a minimum tensile strength of 75
ksi.
|
|
FINISH AND APPEARANCE
It is common to have minor cracks, minor
chipping, or minor imperfections in masonry walls.
These should not be considered as basis for
rejection of work. ASTM C90-01 Standard requires
that when viewed from a distance of not less than
20 feet under diffused lighting, exposed wall
construction shall not show imperfections,
chipping, or cracking. This is considered a general
criterion for accepting appearance.
This issue of Masonry Chronicles was written
by Vilas Mujumdar, Executive Director of Concrete
Masonry Association of California and
Nevada.
|